Skip to content
Skip to product information
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
Description

“You’re So Pretty” started as something Payton Tolle’s mom, Jina, would yell from the stands while he pitched. What once made him laugh — and maybe blush a little — has become one of the ways Payton carries his mom’s memory and joy with him every time he takes the mound.

Created in partnership with Payton, this design celebrates that phrase and the relationship behind it while supporting Empower, an organization providing community and mentorship to children and young adults who have experienced the loss of a parent.

Learn more and support Empower.

  • 100% of proceeds go to supporting Empower
  • Made in partnership with Payton Tolle
  • Officially licensed by MLB Players, Inc.
  • Premium, vintage-inspired fabric — soft, durable, built to last
  • Designed & printed in the USA — launched at game speed
  • Free returns & exchanges — we've got your back, always

Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache

Regular price $ 34.00
  • Adult T-Shirt
  • Hoodie
  • Youth T-Shirt
  • Youth Hoodie
  • Women's V-Neck
  • SMALL
  • MEDIUM
  • LARGE
  • XL
  • 2XL
  • 3XL
Size Chart

WE'RE TRUSTED PARTNERS WITH

MLBPA Logo NFLPA Logo NHLPA Logo WNBPA Logo
Description

“You’re So Pretty” started as something Payton Tolle’s mom, Jina, would yell from the stands while he pitched. What once made him laugh — and maybe blush a little — has become one of the ways Payton carries his mom’s memory and joy with him every time he takes the mound.

Created in partnership with Payton, this design celebrates that phrase and the relationship behind it while supporting Empower, an organization providing community and mentorship to children and young adults who have experienced the loss of a parent.

Learn more and support Empower.

  • 100% of proceeds go to supporting Empower
  • Made in partnership with Payton Tolle
  • Officially licensed by MLB Players, Inc.
  • Premium, vintage-inspired fabric — soft, durable, built to last
  • Designed & printed in the USA — launched at game speed
  • Free returns & exchanges — we've got your back, always

Size Charts

PLAYERS LOVE BREAKINGT

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

  • Andrés Muñoz

  • George Kittle

    Sub heading

  • Kiké Hernández

    Sub heading

  • Gunnar Henderson

    Sub heading

  • Rylie Boone

    Sub heading

  • Elly De La Cruz

    Sub heading

  • Fernando Tatís Jr.

    Sub heading

  • Courtney Vandersloot/Allie Quigley

    Sub heading

  • Alec Bohm

    Sub heading

  • Mookie Betts

    Sub heading

  • Pete Alonso

    Sub heading

  • Leon Draisaitl

    Sub heading

Frequently Asked Questions

Do the t-shirts fit true to size?

Yes, our t-shirts are designed to fit true to size, but if you prefer a looser or more fitted style, we recommend checking our size chart for the best fit.

How soft are the t-shirts?

Our shirts are made with a premium fabric blend that feels incredibly soft and comfortable right from the first wear, giving you the feel of your favorite broken-in tee without sacrificing durability.

What if I’m not satisfied with my purchase?

We offer hassle-free, free returns and exchanges within 60 days of purchase because we want you to love your shirt as much as we do.

QUALITY YOU CAN TRUST

Officially Licensed by Players

We are officially licensed by many of the most popular Player Unions in the world (MLB, NFL, NIL, NHL, WNBA Players, etc.). These designs are approved by the players and their representatives before they ever hit market – with proceeds from every sale going back to the players.

Premium Blend Fabrics

Experience unmatched comfort and a luxurious feel with our premium blend fabrics, designed to keep you looking and feeling good from the stadium tailgate to your couch.

Free Returns and Exchanges

Have any issues with your order? We'll make it right with free returns and exchanges for the first 60 days!

The Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red) shirt captures a heartfelt moment that’s swept through Boston Pro Baseball this season. Inspired by the rookie pitcher’s tribute to his late mother, the phrase “You’re So Pretty” stitched on Tolle’s glove has become a rallying point for fans and players alike. This design celebrates the story that’s brought a new energy to the city’s baseball scene, making it a standout piece for anyone following Tolle’s breakout year.

Bold in red, this shirt is available in both adult and youth sizes, with hoodie options for cooler nights at the ballpark or around the city. Whether you’re searching for a gameday shirt, a playoff shirt, or a licensed player shirt that actually means something, this release fits right in. The design’s timing and backstory make it a conversation starter at watch parties and a thoughtful gift for a fan who appreciates the deeper moments in sports.

Wear it to your next rivalry night or bring it out for the playoff push when every pitch matters. It’s also a great pick for group chats buzzing about Boston’s latest phenom or as a birthday gift for someone who loves a story behind their gear. Officially licensed through the licensed MLBPA collection, this shirt is as authentic as the moment it celebrates.

SOMETHING FOR EVERY FAN

2623665 - Pete Crow-Armstrong: Air PCA
Pete Crow-Armstrong: Air PCA
2623618 - Caleb Williams: Chicago Mustache
Caleb Williams: Chicago Mustache
2623476 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache (Red)
Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Mustache
2623595 - Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Glove
Payton Tolle: You're So Pretty Glove
2623505 - Aroldis Chapman: 400 Saves
Aroldis Chapman: 400 Saves
2623617 - Indiana Football: Run It Back
Indiana Football: Run It Back
2623616 - Indiana Football: It's Simple We Win
Indiana Football: It's Simple We Win
2623668 - Michigan Football: Hail Michigan
Michigan Football: Hail Michigan
2623669 - Michigan Football: A Lot Can Happen In 0:01 Seconds
Michigan Football: A Lot Can Happen In 0:01 Second
2623664 - Adley Rutschman: Home Runs Are Fun, Man
Adley Rutschman: Home Runs Are Fun, Man
Quick links
Trending Shirts
Trending Baseball
Trending Hockey
Trending Football
Trending Players

Copyright© 2026 BreakingT POS and Ecommerce by Shopify

en
United States USD
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
Coupon
Drawer Title
Similar Products